What the Supreme Court Decision Means for Freight Brokers, Shippers, and Safer Supply Chains
The Supreme Court decision in Montgomery v. Caribe Transport II, LLC has changed the way many companies are talking about freight broker responsibility, carrier selection, and transportation risk. For years, some freight brokerage companies relied on federal preemption arguments when plaintiffs tried to bring state negligence claims after accidents involving motor carriers selected by brokers. On May 14, 2026, the Supreme Court ruled that those claims are not automatically blocked when they concern motor vehicle safety.
For shippers, manufacturers, construction companies, distributors, retailers, energy companies, agricultural businesses, and industrial operations, the message is direct. The logistics provider arranging your freight should not be chosen on price alone. Freight transportation services affect safety, delivery performance, customer commitments, insurance exposure, and your company’s reputation.
At Buchanan Logistics, Inc., carrier quality, communication, shipment visibility, transportation planning, and accountability have never been side issues. They are part of how freight should be managed from the first conversation through final delivery.
What Happened in Montgomery v. Caribe Transport?
The case involved a severe truck accident and a claim that C.H. Robinson, the freight broker involved in arranging the shipment, negligently selected Caribe Transport II, LLC and its driver. The plaintiff alleged that the broker knew or should have known that the carrier presented safety concerns before assigning the load.
The legal question before the Court was not whether the broker was ultimately responsible for the crash. That issue still depends on the facts, the evidence, and applicable state law. The question was whether the Federal Aviation Administration Authorization Act, often called the FAAAA, blocked the plaintiff’s negligent hiring claim before it could proceed.
The Supreme Court held that state law negligent hiring claims against freight brokers can fall within the FAAAA safety exception when the claims concern motor vehicles. In plain terms, freight brokers may now face greater legal scrutiny when a plaintiff alleges that an unsafe motor carrier was selected for a shipment.
This does not mean every broker is liable when a trucking accident occurs. It does mean freight broker services, third-party logistics services, and transportation management services will likely be judged more closely by how well they document carrier vetting, safety review, compliance practices, and risk management.
Why This Decision Matters to Businesses That Ship Freight
Many businesses think of a freight broker as a company that finds a truck. That view is too limited. A strong logistics partner should help a customer solve transportation challenges, plan freight movement, coordinate carrier capacity, track shipments, communicate changes, manage documentation, and reduce avoidable risk.
After Montgomery, businesses should ask more pointed questions when choosing a freight brokerage company or third-party logistics provider:
- How does the provider evaluate motor carriers before tendering freight?
- Does the provider review safety ratings, operating authority, insurance, performance history, and compliance concerns?
- How often are carriers reviewed after onboarding?
- Does the provider rely only on a large freight network, or does it manage that network with discipline?
- How does the provider communicate risk, shipment status, and changes during transit?
- Does the provider have experienced transportation professionals who understand complex freight, or is the process mostly transactional?
The cheapest truck is not always the best answer. Low cost transportation can become very expensive if it leads to missed delivery windows, damaged freight, cargo claims, unreliable communication, unsafe carrier selection, or reputational harm with your own customers.
Why Some Brokerages Are Reviewing Their Carrier Networks
Since the Supreme Court ruling, industry reports have noted that some brokerages are tightening carrier requirements and removing carriers that do not meet updated safety or compliance standards. That may appear to be a positive response, and in some ways it is. Stronger standards can improve safety and encourage better industry practices.
Still, businesses should look at that trend carefully. If a brokerage suddenly has to remove questionable carriers from its network after a court decision, customers have a fair reason to ask why those carriers were available before the ruling.
That concern is not about blaming every freight broker. Many brokers and transportation management companies work hard to operate responsibly. The concern is about brokerages that may have been willing to accept weak safety indicators, limited documentation, or questionable carrier performance because the market demanded fast capacity and low freight rates.
Safety should not become important only after litigation risk increases. It should be part of the standard operating process before a load is ever moved.
Why Carrier Selection Is More Than a Back Office Task
Carrier selection affects every party in the freight transportation process. It affects the shipper whose cargo is moving. It affects the driver on the road. It affects the broker or 3PL provider coordinating the load. It affects the customer waiting for delivery. It affects the general public sharing the highway.
Strong carrier management should include practical checkpoints such as:
- Active operating authority and required insurance.
- Safety ratings and publicly available compliance information.
- Equipment suitability for the freight type.
- Experience with the lane, commodity, and delivery requirements.
- Communication standards and tracking expectations.
- History of on-time performance and issue resolution.
- Ability to meet loading, securement, tarping, temperature, oversize, or specialized requirements.
For routine dry van transportation, these details matter. For flatbed transportation, heavy haul transportation services, oversized load transportation, project cargo logistics, industrial freight transportation, and expedited freight transportation, they matter even more.
How Buchanan Logistics Approaches Freight Differently
Buchanan Logistics, Inc. was built from a transportation background, not a purely transactional brokerage model. The Buchanan story began with Geary Buchanan, a former truck driver with decades of hands-on experience in transportation. That operating knowledge helped shape a business culture centered on reliability, service, safety, and long-term relationships.
Today, Buchanan Logistics supports customers throughout the United States, Canada, and Mexico. The company manages freight across many industries and freight types, including dry van, flatbed, drop deck, curtainside, hazmat, heavy haul, expedited freight, specialized transportation, retail freight, construction materials, agricultural equipment, mining components, renewable energy freight, oil and gas freight, industrial equipment, and project cargo.
The company’s scale also matters. Buchanan Logistics points to double-digit year-over-year growth, more than 600 logistics professionals, more than 160,000 loads managed annually, and more than $350 million in revenue as evidence of its capacity and reliability. The company also highlights a 99% on-time pickup and delivery rate, 24/7 support, robust technology, and North American operations that help reduce border-related delays.
Those facts support what many customers already know. Buchanan Logistics is not simply a freight shipping company. It is a transportation solutions provider built to help businesses move freight with better planning, better communication, and stronger accountability.
Safety Is Part of the Buchanan Logistics Culture
Buchanan Logistics does not need to discover safety because of a court ruling. Safety is already stated as one of the company’s core values on the Mission and Family Values page.
The company’s D.I.S.C. values include Determination, Integrity, Safety, and Community. Integrity means doing the right thing even when it is difficult. Safety means strict adherence to regulations, standards, and best practices. These values are not separate from transportation operations. They shape how Buchanan Logistics builds partnerships, communicates with customers, and supports dependable freight movement.
That is important in the current broker liability environment. A logistics company with a safety-minded operating culture is better positioned to serve customers who want confidence, not guesswork.
Buchanan Logistics and Vetted Carrier Relationships
Through its Freight Capabilities, Buchanan Logistics explains that it uses a vast network of more than 9,000 highly vetted carrier partnerships, along with access to its sister company’s owned fleet, to match freight requirements with the right trailer and scheduling solution.
That combination is valuable. Customers benefit from the flexibility of a broad freight network, while also working with a logistics partner that understands equipment, capacity, routing, timing, and customer-specific freight requirements.
Many freight broker companies can say they have access to trucks. Fewer can combine logistics technology, hands-on transportation experience, freight visibility, carrier relationships, specialized freight knowledge, and values rooted in safety and integrity.
What Buchanan Logistics Offers Customers
Buchanan Logistics provides a wide range of freight logistics services for companies that need reliable support across one shipment, one lane, a recurring freight program, or an ongoing transportation strategy.
Core services and capabilities include:
- Freight brokerage services.
- Third-party logistics services.
- Truckload freight services.
- Full truckload shipping.
- Less-than-truckload shipping.
- Dry van transportation.
- Flatbed transportation services.
- Drop deck and step deck freight.
- Heavy haul transportation services.
- Oversized load transportation.
- Specialized freight solutions.
- Expedited freight transportation.
- Cross-border logistics for the United States, Canada, and Mexico.
- Project cargo logistics.
- Industrial freight transportation.
- Construction equipment transportation.
- Supply chain logistics services.
- Transportation management solutions.
- Dedicated transportation support.
- Freight planning and shipment coordination.
These services make Buchanan Logistics a strong choice for businesses looking for one logistics partner that can handle routine shipments, complex freight, time-sensitive freight, and high-touch freight management.
The Buchanan Advantage in a Higher Risk Freight Market
The Buchanan Advantage is especially relevant after the Montgomery decision because it is based on more than load matching. Buchanan Logistics emphasizes advanced technology, real-time tracking, EDI, web billing, project billing, extensive carrier relationships, 24/7 customer support, dedicated points of contact, and reliable service. Plus, Buchanan Logistics, Inc. was founded by a real truck driver and their sister asset-based trucking company, Buchanan Hauling and Rigging, Inc., which has operated for over 30 years.
For customers, those details create practical benefits:
- Better shipment visibility: Customers need to know where freight is, what has changed, and what action is being taken.
- Better transportation planning: Experienced professionals can help match freight to the right equipment and lane strategy.
- Better communication: A dedicated point of contact helps reduce confusion and missed information.
- Better freight execution: Dispatch, coordination, tracking, documentation, and issue resolution are handled by a team that understands logistics operations.
- Better risk awareness: Carrier relationships, safety expectations, and operational discipline help reduce avoidable problems.
In a market where some brokerages are tightening standards after the fact, Buchanan Logistics offers customers a stronger reason to choose an established logistics partner that has already built safety, service, and accountability into its identity.
Why This Ruling Affects More Than Freight Brokers
The Montgomery decision is often discussed as a broker liability case, but its impact reaches beyond freight brokers. Asset-based trucking companies will likely face renewed pressure to review their own hiring practices, driver qualification procedures, safety training, equipment maintenance, documentation, and compliance programs.
If brokers are expected to use care when selecting carriers, motor carriers should expect more questions about how they select, train, supervise, and retain drivers. Shippers may also become more selective about the brokers, carriers, and logistics management services they trust with their freight.
That is not necessarily a bad thing. Higher expectations can help raise the standard across the transportation network. It encourages better documentation, stronger compliance, clearer accountability, and a more serious approach to highway safety.
What Businesses Should Look for in a Freight Brokerage Company
When comparing truck brokerage companies, 3PL services, freight management companies, and transportation network providers, businesses should look beyond price and availability.
A strong logistics partner should be able to explain:
- How carrier qualification works.
- How freight visibility is handled.
- How shipment updates are communicated.
- How pricing is developed.
- How specialized equipment is sourced.
- How service failures are addressed.
- How cross-border logistics are managed.
- How long-term freight programs are supported.
The What to Expect page shows how Buchanan Logistics structures customer onboarding, account management, pricing, bidding, service execution, technology integration, and ongoing support. Customers work with account managers, benefit from 24/7 service, receive shipment tracking, and gain access to transportation professionals who can help solve issues before they grow.
That type of process matters when the freight market is under greater legal, operational, and customer pressure.
How Buchanan Logistics Supports Supply Chain Performance
Transportation problems rarely stay isolated. A missed pickup can affect production. A late delivery can affect installation schedules. A poor carrier match can affect claims, compliance, and customer trust. A lack of communication can turn a manageable issue into a costly disruption.
Buchanan Logistics helps customers improve supply chain performance through freight planning, carrier management, shipment coordination, freight visibility, dedicated logistics support, and transportation expertise.
The company also supports customers through multiple office locations across the country. Its locations page highlights offices that support regional freight markets, nationwide brokerage support, localized management, and North American transportation needs.
For companies with recurring freight, multi-lane RFQs, seasonal projects, plant support, construction projects, retail distribution, industrial equipment moves, or cross-country supply chains, that combination of national reach and local support can make a meaningful difference.
Why Businesses Should Be Concerned About Weak Carrier Standards
Businesses should be concerned when a brokerage treats carrier quality as a secondary issue. A weak carrier selection process can create problems that go far beyond one shipment.
Possible consequences include:
- Increased accident exposure.
- Higher cargo claim risk.
- Late pickups and missed deliveries.
- Poor communication during transit.
- Unqualified equipment for the freight type.
- Improper securement or handling concerns.
- Damage to customer relationships.
- Disruption to production or project timelines.
The Supreme Court decision has made these concerns more visible, but the underlying issue is not new. Responsible freight management has always required more than finding the lowest available rate.
Why Customers Choose Buchanan Logistics
Companies choose Buchanan Logistics because they need a logistics partner that can support freight movement with experience, responsiveness, scale, technology, and values.
Buchanan Logistics gives customers:
- Experience: Nearly three decades of transportation knowledge supports smarter freight decisions.
- Expertise: Teams understand truckload shipping, flatbed freight, heavy haul, specialized freight, expedited freight, and cross-border logistics.
- Authority: Scale, growth, freight volume, carrier relationships, and industry recognition show that Buchanan Logistics is a serious transportation provider.
- Trust: Safety, integrity, communication, and accountability are built into the company’s values and customer process.
- Technology: Shipment tracking, EDI, billing tools, and real-time information help customers stay informed.
- Support: 24/7 service and dedicated account management help customers keep freight moving.
For businesses seeking a reliable logistics provider, a trusted freight partner, or a nationwide logistics company that can support complex transportation needs, Buchanan Logistics offers more than capacity. It offers a disciplined process, experienced people, and a culture built around doing the job the right way.
Questions Shippers Should Ask After Montgomery
Any business that ships freight should use the Montgomery decision as a reason to review its transportation partnerships. Helpful questions include:
- Do we know how our freight broker vets carriers?
- Does our logistics partner provide shipment visibility and proactive communication?
- Are we choosing freight providers based only on price?
- Do we have a clear process for high-value, oversized, expedited, or specialized freight?
- Can our provider support transportation planning across multiple lanes or facilities?
- Does our provider have enough experience to manage unusual freight problems?
- Is safety treated as a value, a process, or only a claim made during sales conversations?
The right answers can help reduce risk, improve shipping efficiency, and protect customer relationships.
Moving Forward With a Safer, Smarter Logistics Partner
The Montgomery v. Caribe Transport decision will continue to influence freight brokerage, carrier management, insurance, litigation, and shipper expectations. It has already caused many in the industry to think harder about carrier selection and safety practices.
For Buchanan Logistics, the ruling supports a principle that has long guided the company. Freight should be managed with integrity, care, communication, and safety in mind.
If your company is reviewing freight brokerage services, transportation management services, truckload shipping, heavy haul transportation, expedited freight, cross-border logistics, or end-to-end logistics solutions, Buchanan Logistics is ready to help.
Learn more about The Buchanan Advantage, review Freight Capabilities, see What to Expect, explore Our Locations, or submit a Rate Request to connect with the Buchanan Logistics team.
When freight, safety, timing, and customer commitments matter, choose a logistics company that treats every shipment like a responsibility, not just a transaction.
Frequently Asked Questions
What did the Supreme Court decide in Montgomery v. Caribe Transport?
The Supreme Court ruled that state law negligent hiring claims against freight brokers are not automatically preempted by the FAAAA when the claims concern motor vehicle safety. This allows certain claims involving negligent carrier selection to proceed under state law.
Can freight brokers be sued for hiring unsafe carriers?
Yes, freight brokers may face negligence claims if a plaintiff alleges that the broker failed to use reasonable care when selecting a motor carrier. The plaintiff still has to prove the claim under applicable law.
Does the Montgomery decision make brokers automatically liable?
No. The decision allows certain claims to proceed, but it does not decide whether a broker is responsible in every case. Liability depends on the facts, the evidence, and the law applied by the court.
Why should shippers care about carrier selection?
Carrier selection affects safety, reliability, claims, communication, delivery performance, and customer trust. Businesses should work with logistics providers that take carrier management seriously.
What is negligent carrier selection?
Negligent carrier selection generally refers to a claim that a broker or company failed to use reasonable care when choosing a motor carrier, especially when safety information suggested the carrier may not have been suitable for the shipment.
How does Buchanan Logistics vet carriers?
Buchanan Logistics works with highly vetted carrier partnerships and uses transportation experience, technology, communication, and carrier relationships to match freight with qualified capacity for the shipment requirements.
What makes Buchanan Logistics different from other freight brokers?
Buchanan Logistics combines transportation experience, a strong carrier network, advanced logistics technology, 24/7 support, customer-focused account management, North American service, and values centered on safety, integrity, and accountability.
Does Buchanan Logistics provide nationwide freight transportation?
Yes. Buchanan Logistics supports freight transportation throughout the United States and provides cross-border logistics solutions for freight moving between the United States, Canada, and Mexico.
What types of freight can Buchanan Logistics manage?
Buchanan Logistics supports dry van, flatbed, drop deck, curtainside, heavy haul, hazmat, expedited freight, specialized transportation, retail freight, construction materials, agricultural equipment, industrial freight, and project cargo.
Does this ruling affect asset-based trucking companies?
Yes. Although the case focuses on freight broker liability, asset-based carriers may also face greater scrutiny regarding driver hiring, training, qualification, equipment maintenance, safety programs, and compliance practices.
Why is safety important in freight brokerage?
Safety matters because freight brokerage decisions affect the carrier, driver, shipper, receiving customer, and the public. A strong safety process helps reduce preventable risk and supports better freight outcomes.
How can I request freight pricing from Buchanan Logistics?
Businesses can submit shipment details through the Buchanan Logistics Rate Request page to begin discussing freight pricing, equipment needs, lanes, and transportation requirements.
Contact us now to get more information
or to get a rate quote for your next project.
Additional Logistics Related Information
Logistics Coordination Explained | Dispatch Brokers in Logistics | Freight Visibility Matters
| Leading Logistics Powered by Technology | Supply Chain Logistics Support
